James's working notes from Western Civ class

Table of Contents

Hegel

Wrote: Intro to Philosophy of HistoryHegel, Intro to Philosophy of History
Intro to Philosophy of History
Written by [[Hegel]]

Themes

Spirit:
consciousness
self-consciousness
freedom
progress of history


Class Notes
![[Hegel, Intro to Philosophy of History.pdf]]

Summary
Hegel wrote about Spirit, and how it is realized. He explained that the essence of Spirit is Freedom, so then he had to talk about Freedom; and that led to a discussion of consciousness (specifically self-consciousness) and existence. You see, Spirit exists in itself, meaning that it is...

Notes

  • absolute idealist
  • key member of German IdealismGerman Idealism
    German Idealism

    Members

    Fichte
    HegelHegel
    Hegel

    Wrote: Intro to Philosophy of HistoryHegel, Intro to Philosophy of History
    Intro to Philosophy of History
    Written by [[Hegel]]

    Themes

    Spirit:
    consciousness
    self-consciousness
    freedom
    progress of history


    Class Notes
    ![[Hegel, Intro to Philosophy of History.pdf]]

    Summary
    Hegel wrote about Spirit, and how it is realized. He explained that the essence of Spirit is Freedom, so then he had to talk about Freedom; and that led to a discussion of consciousness (specifically self-consciousness) and existence. You see, Spirit exists in itself, meaning that it is...


    Notes

    absolute idealist
    key member of German IdealismGerman Idealism
    German Idealism

    Members

    Fichte
    [[Hegel]]
    Schelling
    Spinoza
    Schleiermacher
    [[Schopenhauer]]


    Map of 19th Century Philosophers
    ![[Map of 19th c. philosophers.png]]

    Class Notes

    speculative massive encompassing system
    everything is idea
    grew out of trying to complete [[Kant]] (Transcendental Idealism)

    Kant's epistemology of the phenomena & noumena (the thing in itself); the noumena is unknowable
    Fichte combines the phenomena & noumena; everything th...

    student of Fichte & relied on him in his work
    the great intellect is not personal & is accessible to man b/c man's intellect is an extension of its intellect
    view of history

    teleological development - development in a direction (Darwin takes this and runs w/ it)
    history recognizes internal contradictions and s...

    Schelling
    Spinoza
    Schleiermacher
    [[Schopenhauer]]


    Map of 19th Century Philosophers
    ![[Map of 19th c. philosophers.png]]

    Class Notes

    speculative massive encompassing system
    everything is idea
    grew out of trying to complete KantKant
    Kant
    Wrote [[Kant, What is Enlightenment?]]
    Man's primary problem isn't sin; it's that he doesn't have the freedom to reason & be enlightened (??)

    Background

    came from Prussia, wrote under Frederick the Great
    Kant - a rationalist who wants to confine reason to the bounds of experience

    reason is bound by the condition of possible experience; cannot reason about unexperienced things
    so, we can't reason a/b God crating the world because we didn't experience it


    ...
    (Transcendental Idealism)

    Kant's epistemology of the phenomena & noumena (the thing in itself); the noumena is unknowable
    Fichte combines the phenomena & noumena; everything th...
  • student of Fichte & relied on him in his work
  • the great intellect is not personal & is accessible to man b/c man's intellect is an extension of its intellect
  • view of history
    • teleological development - development in a direction (Darwin takes this and runs w/ it)
    • history recognizes internal contradictions and seeks to fix them
      • e.g. in America, all men are free, but there were also slaves; history then corrected that contradiction
    • the better-developed the World-Spirit is, the more freely it can act
  • substitutes reason for religion
    • KierkegaardKierkegaard
      Kierkegaard
      Notes

      took Hegel's historical progress model and applied that to people

      Parts of a life

      aesthetic - devoted to the things around you
      ethical - rule following
      religious - existentially committed to the infinite


      life is about dealing w/ internal contradictions in yourself
      inwardness - who you are underneath the external layers that others see

      critizing the very superficial state churc...
      critizes him for rationalizing religions existential parts

Later

  • Young Hegelians
    • reason & freedom, keep them guiding forward
    • ditched Hegel's politics & religion
    • Feuerbach, MarxMarx
      Marx
      Notes

      alienation of labor is bad ([[Romanticism|a romantic tendency]])
      solution: new economic system

  • Right Hegelians
    • develop Hegel's political statism
    • Germany has reached the top, so now we conserve it
    • but still insist on a personal God
    • its different eras affected the development of Christianity